Remember those lame Internet filters which my faithful readers helped the smut-hungry youth of Australia to dismantle, last year?
Well, the whole taxpayer-funded content-control software handout program has now officially been declared (by Australia's new Federal Labor government) to be a miserable failure.
Apart from the fact that the NetAlert packages were quite easy to get around, it turned out that nobody actually very much wanted them.
The Government predicted that 2.5 million households, about 31% of the whole country, would want their free copy of one or another of the packages (which they'd paid for with their taxes already, of course).
As it turns out, they got a grand total of 144,088 CD orders and downloads.
And not all of the people who got the filter software bothered to use it. The ridiculously-named government department responsible says only about 29,000 of the packages were actually installed.
That's 1.2% of the target, for those of you keeping score at home.
The total price of the software filter scheme was 85 million Australian dollars. That's about $US78 million, at current exchange rates.
So this software ended up costing the taxpayer about $AU2930 ($US2685) per installed unit.
A copy of Net Nanny will cost you $US27 from Amazon. That's almost exactly one per cent of the effective price of the "free" software.
All that, to stop red-blooded Aussie kids from seeing boobies and doodles.
But have no fear - the new Federal government is much more sensible! They enthusiastically explain that their own very expensive scheme to implement "mandatory ISP-based filtering to deliver a filtered feed to all homes, schools and public internet points" will work far better. You know, just as it has in the other countries that've implemented secret Internet blacklists which, in effect, accuse lots of random innocent people of being child pornographers.
Never mind that, despite more than $15 million worth of advertising (including a booklet sent to every household in the country), it is now demonstrable that approximately three-fifths of bugger-all Australians have any interest in filtering their own Internet connection.
No, never mind that. We must be protected from filthy filthy porn, whether we want to be or not!
This is all more evidence that, as I've said before, it doesn't matter whether censorware works. Which is good, because it generally doesn't.
The purpose of censorware is not to Protect The Children, but to get some people elected and keep other people employed.
22 February 2008 at 10:55 am
How do they know that "only about 29,000 of the packages were actually installed".
Does the software phone home?
22 February 2008 at 12:32 pm
Don't say that!
Half of the people who actually installed the software will now have a collective heart attack over 'governent monitoring' and uninstall it again!
22 February 2008 at 2:00 pm
I heard about this a while ago and I still feel compelled to bitch and moan at a politician about it. Unfortunately the Australia branch of the EFF does a pretty terrible job of getting the general public to do anything. Where our Canadian style protests and information on how to yell at the government? Their site simply has a press release saying they don't like it.
22 February 2008 at 4:56 pm
Hack on Triple J had a segment this afternoon saying more-or-less exactly what Dan did.
It'll be available on their podcast here soon.
22 February 2008 at 7:18 pm
Ah, Moral Panic.
If you ban everything someone doesn't like, you wind up with nothing anyone likes.
Say, whatever happened to that generation whose moral compasses were degaussed by listening to jazz music/Elvis/the Beatles?
23 February 2008 at 4:03 am
Oooo! Don't get me started on that Elvis fellow! His hips are the devils work I tell ya! His dancing makes me feel things that are just not appropriate good moral christian feelings! And those british hippies - what are they called again? The bugs or something? Ooo they all oughtta be locked away! ;)
23 February 2008 at 1:36 pm
Off your meds again, Stark? Good boy. ;-)
24 February 2008 at 5:12 am
... and you don't even need to pay for NetNanny.
K9 from Blue Coatdoes a better job in my experience, and it's actually free, not taxpayer funded free.
27 February 2008 at 8:23 am
As to the ISP filtering idea - it will never happen , the previous government tried to do the same thing with a resounding "piss off" from the ISP's